Remember all those apples from
this day? What I forgot to tell you then was that we picked a total of 75 apples! Then we divided that up between the 3 couples. So what did I do with 25 apples? Made apple pie!.... twice. Once was for the Pumpkin Carving party. Then I was begged into making another to share with my friend Erika. (How dare she!) But that meant Jesse and I got to eat a couple more slices two.
Here's what I did. And I promise it was delicious. Some said it was the best apple pie of their life. Now, it
could have been due to the fresh-from-the-farm apples, but I'll take the flattery. ;)
But first, let's have a chat about apple pie. It's quite an important topic, or at least has been in our relationship. Apple pie is Jesse's
favorite dessert. But not just
any ole apple pie. Not one from the deli of the grocery store. And definitely not those in the little sleeves from McDonald's (do they still have those?!). It takes a homemade, made-from-scratch apple pie to please this man. I learned this early on in our relationship and slaved away over a few of them while trying to woo him. My step-dad thought I was going to lose fingers over sliced apples once.
After preparing my very first pie, and bringing it to him with a huge smile on my face, I'm sure he said it was delicious, but he had to tell me that the
next time I made one I should slice the apples
really thin, just like.... his
mom does it! Ladies, when your mother-in-law is a good cook, you gotta step up your game! Lesson learned: always consult the mama. So I did, and she told me about this thing known as a mandolin slicer. It really does make all the difference for the pie. Thinly sliced apples lay flatter against each other and make it easier to cut with your fork and eat. It also lets you pack in lots of apples, and we like more apples and less "sauce". And now you know our secret!
This is not Marilyn's actual recipe, but for this pie I combined a crust and filling recipe, mostly adapted for my pantry. There is also method to this madness, which I learn the first go-round.
Click
HERE for the recipe I used (and to print it).
Anything that begins with two sticks of butter is likely to be tasty, so go ahead and cube those two sticks, then put it back into the refrigerator. (This was the moment that my beloved camera died a sad and sudden death. I think I had a couple of pictures of...butter... but I've been too lazy to get them off the card. I grabbed my phone to take the rest of the pictures, so excuse the quality. These events will not effect the taste of your pie.)
Measure out your flour, sugar, and salt for your pie crust. This time I made a revelation: I threw all of this into my stand mixer, turned it on "stir," and added the butter several pieces at a time. Just like when you use a pastry blender (which I don't have, which is why I was improvising) you want the dough to go from powdery to tiny, little pea-sized clumps. Once the butter is all cut into the flour mixture, add a couple of tablespoons of ice water, one at a time until the dough starts to stick together. Be careful not to over-do it here, especially with the mixer which works fast. The less you mix it, the flakier your crust will be. Once it just begins to hold, stop mixing, and dump it onto your work surface. (I like using this silicone mat. It's like a Silpat, but from Aldi. Aka - cheaper. You're supposed to be able to bake on them, but that seems a little weird to me. Moving on...)
Divide your dough into two, and pat into rounds. Wrap them in plastic-wrap and pop them in the fridge to keep chilled.
Now work on your apples. Use a mandolin slicer, or just a knife and more patience than I have, and cut up your apples. It will probably take about 8 mid to large-sized apples to fill out your pie. I didn't have any lemon juice to toss mine with, so I tried to work extra fast. This is also the time you add all of your sugar and spices to the apples, tossing to coat each slice. Some recipes call for letting the apples sit in this sugar mixture for some time to let more juices flow. I prefer to keep on going without this step, mostly because by this point I can't wait to get the thing into the oven, because the sooner it's in, the sooner it's out and I can eat a slice. Plus it turns out just right with plenty of juice/moisture.
Next up, roll out your bottom crust. You may need to let it sit out a bit to warm up if you've made it ahead of time and it's really cold. I like to smush the edges to keep the shape round as I roll, like this:
Once you've roll to size, flour the top surface and roll it up on your rolling pin (dusting the bottom of the crust with flour as you pull it off the counter). Then drape it into your pie dish.
Dump in your apples. Smile because you're almost done, and this is going to be amazing.
Roll out your top crust, and roll it up onto your rolling pin, like before.
Top your pie with crust, and trim any excessive edges. Leave about an inch all the way around so you can tuck the top crust under the bottom crust, and pinch them together. Make the edge as pretty as you want. I used a fork to press and seal all the way around. At this point I realized that I did not add the additional tabs of butter on top of the apples that was in the recipe I was following. After a slight moment of panic I decided that the two stick of butter in the crust would suffice, and it was true! No butter was missed, and we saved a few calories, right?
Brush the top with egg wash, cut a few small slits, sprinkle with a little sugar, and pop it in the oven.
And there you have it! Glorious apple pie. Deliciousness that taste like Fall. And your house smells all cinnamony (unless your pie dripped into the bottom of the stove and burned.... yep. Prevent that by putting an aluminum foil lined cookie sheet on the rack below - next time, next time). And enjoy! With a scoop of vanilla ice cream, of course. Can't forget that!
What's your favorite pie to make? Or your favorite pie to eat during the Fall?
